BANNING PEOPLE WITH DISABILTY Decision Against Rights

The decision of government to ban blind people and double amputees from climbing has sparked criticism

Jan. 8, 2018, 7:40 a.m. Published in Magazine Issue: VOL.11, No.12, January 05, 2018 (Poush21, 2074) Online Register Number: DOI 584/074-75

Preparing for more than a year to climb Mt. Everest, Hari Budha Magar, a Gurkha soldier, who lost both legs in an explosion in Afghanistan and is training to become the first above-knee double amputee to climb Everest, is the first victim of Nepal government’s recent decision to ban blind people and double amputees from climbing mountains.

“Nepal should be proud of me, not ban me,” he wrote on Facebook. “I will be climbing Everest whatever the cabinet decides. Nothing is impossible,” said Magar in his voice of frustration. However, Nepal’s government officials do not seem to have any sympathetic tone to people with disabilities. 

Nepal Disabled Federation and Nepal Blind Association have jointly issued a statement accusing the government of not respecting them. They are considering holding a public rally against the decision.

As Nepal’s constitution also guarantees the rights of people with disability, the new regulations are also against the constitution. As Nepal is also a party of an international convention on right to protect the people with disability, this decision also violates the international convention.

The ban was also criticized by the US ambassador to Nepal, Alaina B Teplitz, who tweeted: “Ability not perceived ‘disability’ must guide rules on who can trek Everest. Climbers like Hari Budha Magar shouldn’t be banned because of false assumptions about capabilities. Accessible tourism for ALL will make it clear that Nepal welcomes everyone!”

At a time there is a wave to include all the persons in society and protect their rights, Nepal government’s decision to ban the double amputees and blind people has badly damaged Nepal’s image worldwide.US ambassador and British Ambasador with.jpg

The government claims that the new regulations aimed at reducing accidents. The regulation also prohibits solo ascents. After the promulgation of the new rule, solo climbers, blind people, and double amputees have been banned from climbing Mt. Sagarmatha.

The changes have provoked criticism from the US ambassador to Nepal and a former Gurkha soldier planning to scale the peak after losing both legs in Afghanistan. According to an official, the new rules have been under discussion for a month and were implemented this week.

 Individual climbers will need to be accompanied by a mountain guide, and high-altitude workers who accompany expeditions to the summit are eligible to receive summit certificates under the revised regulations.

A suggested upper age limit of 76 for climbers – which Nepalese alpine associations had lobbied for after the death of an 85-year-old climber in May – has not been implemented, but the government maintained the ban on climbers under 16.

Everest once attracted only elite climbers, but as the relative cost of scaling the peak has fallen, the mountain has drawn record numbers of aspiring mountaineers, including many from China and India.

Experienced climbers have raised concern that the mountain is becoming dangerously overcrowded and that new companies with lower safety standards have rushed to fill demand in the market.

The Nepalese government tightens the eligibility criteria for permits to scale the 8,848m (29,029ft) peak from the Nepal side before each spring climbing season, but enforcement is patchy and rules are frequently overlooked.

One veteran climber, Alan Arnette, said the ban on amputee and visually impaired climbers was prejudiced, ignorant and irrational. “If this is about protecting people from their own ambitions, then over half of the annual climbers should be banned each year as they lack the experience to safely climb Everest,” he wrote on his blog.

“And where does this stop – people with asthma, diabetes, hemophiliacs or cancer? All of these have recently successfully summited Everest with no problems.”

According to the Himalayan Database, 29 people with disabilities have attempted to climb Everest, and 15 have reached the top. Two – Phur Yemba Sherpa in 2014 and Thomas Weber in 2006 – died on the mountain.

Another 288 non-disabled people have died on Everest from 8,306 attempts since 1953. Six people died this year, and 648 reached the summit, the second-highest in a single climbing season. Around 237 climbed from the Tibetan side.

 

More on Tourism

The Latest

Latest Magazine

VOL.11, No.18, April 06, 2018 (Chaitra 23, 2074) Online Register Number: DOI 584/074-75

VOL.11, No.17, March 23, 2018 (Chaitra 09, 2074) Online Register Number: DOI 584/074-75

VOL.11, No.16, March 02, 2018 (Falgun 18, 2074) Online Register Number: DOI 584/074-75

VOL.11, No.15, February 16, 2018 (Falgun 04, 2074) Online Register Number: DOI 584/074-75